Am I getting Hosed?
Auto-Forums.net Forum Index Auto-Forums.net
Discussion of automobiles and popular brands
 
 FAQFAQ   MemberlistMemberlist     RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 
 
Google
 
Web auto-forums.net
 
Am I getting Hosed?

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Auto-Forums.net Forum Index -> Porsche
Author Message
Bill Branum
Guest





Posted: Mon Nov 08, 2004 2:52 pm    Post subject: Am I getting Hosed? Reply with quote

I bought my new 2000 S from a dealer 200 miles away from where I live
in April 2001. After an unsatisfactory experience with the initial
15K maintenance from the local Porsche dealer, the dealer I purchased
my car from agreed to give a 10% discount on all service as an
incentive to drive the 200 miles to have them do it.

I am now approaching 150K on the vehicle and I have had this dealer do
all scheduled maintenances, repairs, as well as new tires and
alignment with every 30K maintenance. I have 18" rims and always go
with Pirelli P-Zero tires. Each time I had a service done I asked if
my discount was included. The first few times they would manually
mark down the ticket 10%, but for the past couple of years they have
assured my the discount was included. As I had built up a level of
trust (always the same people, zero turnover) I took their word for it
and didn't check the numbers.

Last week I took the car in for a new rear tire, two front tires, and
an alignment (I had to replace one of the rear tires 2 weeks earlier
at a local tire store). My bill was $1191, and this didn't seem
right, so I questioned if the 10% discount was included. Once again I
was assured it was. The alignment itself was billed out at $385, and
I questioned that, stating that I thought alignment was more in the
$250 range. I was told the normal price for alignment is $420. When
I got home I checked my prior service records, and sure enough, I had
been billed $240 for alignment at 90K but had been billed $385 for
alignment at 120K (my service records for prior to the 90K maintenance
are in storage). Also, the prices charged for the same tires are
varying from $210 to $305!

So, what do most dealerships charge for an alignment? Are
independents properly equipped and trained to do alignments a 2000
Boxster S? If so, what is their typical charge? Do most of you buy
your tires from the dealer? What about buying tires over the internet
and having a local tire shop install them?

Also, is there a guide as to how many hours should be charged for
secluded maintenances (and maybe other repairs also)? If so, this
dealer has a posted labor rate of $69.50 per hour, is that in line
with other Porsche dealerships?

Thanks in Advance for your help.

Bill

Back to top
Jim Keenan
Guest





Posted: Mon Nov 08, 2004 6:45 pm    Post subject: Re: Am I getting Hosed? Reply with quote

Bill Branum wrote:
Quote:

Also, the prices charged for the same tires are
varying from $210 to $305!

I have P Zero Rossos on a 2002 996, and the rears (285/30-18) are about
$300 each.
Quote:

So, what do most dealerships charge for an alignment? Are
independents properly equipped and trained to do alignments a 2000
Boxster S? If so, what is their typical charge? Do most of you buy
your tires from the dealer? What about buying tires over the internet
and having a local tire shop install them?

We have two Porsche dealers in our locale - one does tire sales and
installs in house, the other sends the work out. I bought my first set
of rears from my dealer, who does the work in house. His price was
better than the shop the other dealer uses, but not as good as a well
known national chain store also in the area. I went with the dealer on
the theory that they specialize in my car ( and there was other service
being done as well). The dealer scratched both wheels, but also replaced
the damaged parts when I pointed it out to them. I've used the national
chain store frequently for other cars and have usually been happy, but I
also suspect they tweaked the frame of one car due to sloppy positioning
on the lift, although I can't say for sure. If you opt to buy over the
internet, make sure the "local tire shop" knows what they're doing.
Quote:

Also, is there a guide as to how many hours should be charged for
secluded maintenances (and maybe other repairs also)? If so, this
dealer has a posted labor rate of $69.50 per hour, is that in line
with other Porsche dealerships?

My dealer (San Diego County, California) has a posted labor rate
slightly over $100 an hour.....
Quote:
Thanks in Advance for your help.

Bill
Back to top
fbloogyudsr
Guest





Posted: Mon Nov 08, 2004 10:10 pm    Post subject: Re: Am I getting Hosed? Reply with quote

"Bill Branum" <Bill@nospam.Branum.com> wrote
Quote:
Last week I took the car in for a new rear tire, two front tires, and
an alignment (I had to replace one of the rear tires 2 weeks earlier
at a local tire store). My bill was $1191, and this didn't seem
right, so I questioned if the 10% discount was included. Once again I
was assured it was. The alignment itself was billed out at $385, and
I questioned that, stating that I thought alignment was more in the
$250 range. I was told the normal price for alignment is $420. When
I got home I checked my prior service records, and sure enough, I had
been billed $240 for alignment at 90K but had been billed $385 for
alignment at 120K (my service records for prior to the 90K maintenance
are in storage). Also, the prices charged for the same tires are
varying from $210 to $305!

When my wife took her Boxster to the dealer for it's 45K, they
wanted to do front pads/rotors and a brake system flush for $850.
I bought the rotors/pads online for $200 and had the local guy do
the rest for about $90.
I would think an alignment at any normal shop would be around
$150 or so.
If you look online at tirerack.com you'll see that their price for P0 tires
are $180 front, $240 rear. Prices at Discount Dire (tires.com) and
other shops that carry them will be comparable (plus around $15
per tire mounting/balancing.)

By going to the dealer, you are paying for the convenience of one-stop
repairs/maintenance. As you can see, you're paying *a lot* for that.

Quote:
Also, is there a guide as to how many hours should be charged for
secluded maintenances (and maybe other repairs also)? If so, this
dealer has a posted labor rate of $69.50 per hour, is that in line
with other Porsche dealerships?

$70 is really cheap; the rate at Barrier in Bellevue, WA is $99.
You may not know, but most repair shops have a set rate for
each repair - it comes out of a book: x hours for service y, z
hours to change the fanbelt, etc. This is IMO a rip off that always
favors the shop. It was instituted by the manufacturers so that
they didn't pay exorbitant prices for warranty work, and it's
supposed to also favor consumers if the work turns out harder than
it's supposed to be.

Floyd

Back to top
Vern
Guest





Posted: Tue Nov 09, 2004 6:32 am    Post subject: Re: Am I getting Hosed? Reply with quote

My god, I am glad I know how, and have the tools to do this stuff myself.

The question I have to ask is what do you do to make the cash to pay for
your Porsche habit?

Do you need some help?

Back here in Iowa if you have a Porsche, you do it all yourself, no other
way. Unless you want to put a full half the miles on the car getting it
serviced, well now that wouldn't be all that bad now thinking about it.

Anyway, to your question, as a mechanic, NO, your not getting hosed.

I worked on cars for a while, and you know what?
I worked my butt off and saved every penny I could for the customers, only
to have them complain about my work or the bill, not once in a while, EVERY
time. The world has been less one mechanic since my one year endeavor into
it, 32 years ago.

It costs a TON of money for all those special tools and books that usually
the boss don't pay for. Consider your discount as a tip. You give a waitress
15% for Christ's sake, what do they offer? Ohhh, lets not go there.

"fbloogyudsr" <fbloogyudsr@nwlink.com> wrote in message
news:10ova583cktfb0b@corp.supernews.com...
Quote:
"Bill Branum" <Bill@nospam.Branum.com> wrote
Last week I took the car in for a new rear tire, two front tires, and
an alignment (I had to replace one of the rear tires 2 weeks earlier
at a local tire store). My bill was $1191, and this didn't seem
right, so I questioned if the 10% discount was included. Once again I
was assured it was. The alignment itself was billed out at $385, and
I questioned that, stating that I thought alignment was more in the
$250 range. I was told the normal price for alignment is $420. When
I got home I checked my prior service records, and sure enough, I had
been billed $240 for alignment at 90K but had been billed $385 for
alignment at 120K (my service records for prior to the 90K maintenance
are in storage). Also, the prices charged for the same tires are
varying from $210 to $305!

When my wife took her Boxster to the dealer for it's 45K, they
wanted to do front pads/rotors and a brake system flush for $850.
I bought the rotors/pads online for $200 and had the local guy do
the rest for about $90.
I would think an alignment at any normal shop would be around
$150 or so.
If you look online at tirerack.com you'll see that their price for P0
tires
are $180 front, $240 rear. Prices at Discount Dire (tires.com) and
other shops that carry them will be comparable (plus around $15
per tire mounting/balancing.)

By going to the dealer, you are paying for the convenience of one-stop
repairs/maintenance. As you can see, you're paying *a lot* for that.

Also, is there a guide as to how many hours should be charged for
secluded maintenances (and maybe other repairs also)? If so, this
dealer has a posted labor rate of $69.50 per hour, is that in line
with other Porsche dealerships?

$70 is really cheap; the rate at Barrier in Bellevue, WA is $99.
You may not know, but most repair shops have a set rate for
each repair - it comes out of a book: x hours for service y, z
hours to change the fanbelt, etc. This is IMO a rip off that always
favors the shop. It was instituted by the manufacturers so that
they didn't pay exorbitant prices for warranty work, and it's
supposed to also favor consumers if the work turns out harder than
it's supposed to be.

Floyd
Back to top
ethnopac
Guest





Posted: Sun Nov 28, 2004 5:18 pm    Post subject: Re: Am I getting Hosed? Reply with quote

Just for the records: Porsche in Germany charges 100 Euro per hour plus
tax. If IŽd find a place that would charge only 70 it would be worth the
ride.

Markus
Back to top
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Auto-Forums.net Forum Index -> Porsche All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Ford Dealer - Finance Directory




Contact Us
Powered by phpBB